Skip to content

Free shipping on orders over $60

Comparisons 2 min read

Is the Kirkland Signature ball as good as a Pro V1?

Both are three-piece urethane balls. How Costco's Kirkland Signature compares with the Titleist Pro V1 on feel, spin, consistency and price.

By MGB Golf

Kirkland Signature golf ball in white, showing the logo and number Kirkland Signature
Titleist Pro V1 golf ball in white, showing the logo and number Titleist Pro V1

When Costco started selling a three-piece urethane golf ball under its Kirkland Signature label, golfers took notice. Here was a ball built like a tour ball for a fraction of the price. Years and several generations later, people still ask whether it holds up against the Pro V1.

What they share

Both are three-piece balls with urethane covers, the soft cover that grips a wedge and makes chips check up. That's the big thing most distance balls don't have, and it's why the Kirkland gets compared to tour balls at all.

Where they differ

  • Generations. The Kirkland has changed over the years, and generations feel and fly differently. Ours are Performance+ and later, mixed. The Pro V1 is sold by generation, so you can pick Newest Gen or mixed recent years.
  • Feel and flight. The Pro V1 has a soft-but-solid feel and a mid, penetrating flight.
  • Availability. New Kirklands need a Costco membership and usually come in a two-dozen box. Used, you can buy one dozen.
  • Price. The Kirkland is the cheapest way into a urethane ball. The Pro V1 costs more, used or new.

Which should you play?

Play the Kirkland if you want urethane spin on a budget, lose a few balls a round, or want a step up from a two-piece distance ball without paying tour prices.

Play the Pro V1 if you want the benchmark: a consistent, current-generation ball that flies and feels the same from box to box.

Kirkland in Pristine condition

We offer Kirkland in Pristine condition, which is Mint with nothing on it: no pen marks, no dots or lines, no logos. Clean enough to pass for a sleeve straight off the shelf. It also comes in Mint, in white or yellow.

The honest answer

For a lot of golfers, the Kirkland is plenty of ball. For players chasing consistency, the Pro V1 is still the standard. Buy a dozen of each and find out which one you are.

Shop Kirkland Signature · Shop Pro V1

Shop this guide

The balls in this guide

  • Kirkland Signature

    Kirkland Signature

    Choose Color
    Choose Grade

    $10.99 /dz · Save up to 5%

  • Titleist

    Pro V1

    Choose Color
    Choose Grade

    $26.99 /dz · Save up to 5%

Ball Finder

Still not sure? Let us pick.

Answer a few quick questions about your swing, short game and feel, and we'll match you with the used balls that fit.

Take the Ball Finder

More guides

All guides

Your cart

MGB Golf mascot

Nothing but smoke.

Your cart's empty. Free shipping over $60, and 3 dozen saves 5%.

Shop best sellers

MGB Golf mascot

The MGB list

The MGB list

15% off your first order.

Join the list for restocks, new releases and the odd deal. About twice a month, never spam.

Unsubscribe anytime.